Dear
Dr Lehar,
We
have received the reports from our advisors on your manuscript
AACA-D-14-00168R2 "Double Conformal Mapping: A Finite Mathematics to
Model an Infinite World.".
With
regret, I must inform you that, based on the advice received, I have
decided that your manuscript cannot
be accepted for publication in Advances in Applied
Clifford Algebras.
Below,
please find the comments for your perusal. You are kindly requested to
also check the website for possible reviewer attachment(s).
I
would like to thank you very much for forwarding your manuscript to us
for consideration and wish you every success in finding an alternative
place of publication.
With
kind regards,
Guest
Editors of S.I. : From Signals, Images, Transforms Using Clifford
Algebras
Guest
Editor
Advances
in Applied Clifford Algebras
COMMENTS
TO THE AUTHOR:
Dear
Dr. Steven Lehar,
Thank
you for your response to the reviewers. Though, we are aware, that it is
not always possible to follow all the suggestions of the reviewers, in
this case we feel it is impossible for us
to publish the paper as it is. We would at least have
expected on your side to partially make use of the detailed suggestions
of the reviewers in order to improve your paper. By inviting for the
review of your first revision a new independent reviewer, who really
reviewed your paper in great detail, we wanted to avoid being biased. I
also discussed the matter repeatedly with my special issue co-editor
Prof. Bayro-Corrochano. We are sorry for the negative outcome this time.
With
kind regards,
Eckhard
Hitzer