For each category (significance, originality, generality, etc.) a tally is shown of which of the reviewers rated the paper as "acc", "min", "maj", or "not" (whatever those mean! My guess is "acceptable", "minor complaints", "major complaints", and "not acceptable")
[1a] significance:
acc 1 2 4
min
maj 3
not
[1b] originality:
acc 1 3 4
min 2
maj
not
[1c] generality:
acc 3 4
min 1 2
maj
not
[2] presentation:
acc 1 2 4
min
maj 3
not
[3] scholarship:
acc 4
min 1
maj 2 3
not
[4] evidence:
acc 2 4
min 1 3
maj
not
[5] reasoning:
acc 1 4
min 2 3
maj
not
[6] theory:
acc 4
min 1 2 3
maj
not
[7} length:
acc 1 2 4
min
maj 3
not
disposition
acc 1 4
min
maj 2 3
not
els