This is the most ABSURD argument I have ever heard! Really now - if this guy was not protected by reviewer anonymity he would never dare make such a foolish idiotic statement if he were to be held accountable for it!

So what is he saying? That conscious experience can be neither in your head, nor in the world around us, nor is it projected out of our head into the world, but actually all three are simultaneously true?!?! Or does he mean that none of them is true? That consciousness is experienced but it does not actually exist in any physical form in any physical space? Or does he mean that all of them are true and none of them are true all at the same time?

This is what is wrong with the anonymous peer review process! Who is this masked man? Do you have the balls to take off your mask and look me in the eye as you make your absurd statements?