"If they really believe this to be a historical fact, they should at least make a list of all the gestaltists 'other ideas' and document for each of them exactly how it was developed from the 'illusion of consciousness'"

HAHAHAHAHA! And thats just what it would take to convince this reviewer!

Although I doubt even that would really convince him!

Who ARE these people! And how dare they hide behind their annonymity while rejecting other people's papers!